1
1
1
2
3
CEDARTOWN, GA — A Cedartown police officer who shot and killed a baby donkey while helping search for a missing child has been reinstated to duty, months after the incident drew widespread outrage. Officer Trenton Garner was placed on administrative leave after the late-August shooting at Elsberry Farm in Cedartown, where he had gone with other officers and a bloodhound team looking for a 12-year-old girl.
According to official records, the reinstatement became effective immediately after Cedartown Police Chief and the city manager approved it. The move followed a November 3 decision by the Tallapoosa Circuit District Attorney’s Office to clear Garner of criminal charges. The case had sparked intense attention because the animal, named HeeHaw, had become the focus of online anger after video and images spread widely.
Garner said in the incident report that officers followed footprints along a trail that led them to a pasture on the farm. He said the team entered the area because of the urgency of finding the missing juvenile, and a K-9 handler reported seeing a donkey in the field that began charging toward them.
The officer said the animal was first tased in an effort to stop it, but that did not work. Garner then drew his Glock 17 and fired one shot at the male donkey. He said he acted to protect himself, the K-9 officer and the bloodhound team. The girl the officers were searching for was later found in the direction the bloodhounds had been tracking before the encounter.
Tallapoosa Circuit District Attorney Jaeson Smith said Garner had the legal right to enter the property and defend himself from what he believed was a threat. WXIA reported that Smith relied in part on claims that the donkey had a history of attacking people and noted that some of the photographs circulating online after the shooting were alleged to have been staged.
A neighbor also told reporters that HeeHaw had attacked him before. He said the one-year-old donkey was not kept in petting zoos because it would jump on people and bite them. Those claims stood in sharp contrast to the emotional response from the donkey’s owner and supporters, who viewed the shooting as unnecessary and cruel.
HeeHaw’s owner, Hannah Israel, said she bottle-fed the donkey from infancy and believed it was worth about $6,000 because of the care she had given it. She said the animal would not act aggressively toward people and would never try to bite anyone.
Israel’s legal team said the shooting was unjustified and argued that no one was truly in danger. Her attorney told Fox 5 that there was no universe in which the donkey posed a threat. Israel also said she had not received official court paperwork confirming that the charges had been dropped.
The killing of HeeHaw set off anger far beyond Georgia after photos and details of the encounter spread online. Garner was a relatively new officer, having been sworn onto the force in July 2023, and the animal’s death quickly became a lightning rod in a story that mixed a missing-child search, law-enforcement tactics and animal welfare concerns.
The incident report, as described by officials, says the officers had been tracking the girl with bloodhounds when the donkey encountered the team. That sequence became central to the public debate over whether the shooting was a split-second safety decision or an avoidable loss of a beloved farm animal.
After the shooting, Israel launched a fundraising page in HeeHaw’s honor. In her appeal, she described him as a bottle baby donkey who was killed in his own pasture by trespassing officers and said he had brought joy to people through petting zoos and family visits.
So far, the campaign has collected $167,652. Israel said the money will go to a foundation created in HeeHaw’s name and will also help care for the other animals on the farm. The fundraising total shows that, even after the criminal case was resolved, the emotional fallout from the shooting has not faded.
Garner’s return to duty closes one chapter of the case, at least administratively, but it does not erase the public anger that followed the shooting. The reinstatement signals that Cedartown leaders accepted the district attorney’s conclusion that the officer’s actions were legally defensible under the circumstances described in the incident report.
At the same time, the case remains a reminder of how quickly a routine search can turn into a local and national controversy. For Cedartown police, the decision restores a sworn officer to active status after nearly three months on leave. For HeeHaw’s owner and supporters, it leaves unanswered questions about whether the death of a bottle-fed farm animal was ever necessary.